Recently I came across two instances where it can be easily established Digital India would not succeed if entrenched style of functioning to ward off future problem is not done away with.
Government departments are not ready to come out of orthodoxy. They would keep business as usual. To substantiate, I would put two recent happenings.
First: My brother passed the medical entrance test, AIPMT. It was riddled with inefficiency, was conducted twice because of reports of cheating first time. With the result came the moments of celebrations, he had qualified the exam but that celebration was moving us forward to one month of complete exhaustion of mind and body. It was joy to do counseling on-line, we had not to travel anywhere but with the allocation of seat in Bettiah, Bihar started the exhausting journey of coming next month.
MCC's rule states that you have to report at alloted college if you want to continue with second and third round of counseling. My father and brother started from Jaipur and reached the place in around 30 hours. After reporting they came here again in next 30 hours. A travel of 3-4 days continuously! Due to session being late, candidates were given less time to report.
When they arrived here, counseling of our state for reserved 85% seats for state candidates had started. My brother was alloted GMC, Kota this time. The place was near but we could not report to the college because we had submitted our documents with last alloted college through AIPMT, in Bihar. MCC's site provided that you may take On-line Resignation Letter and an affidavit-that you have submitted your document with the last alloted college- and report to alloted college. But there was no co-ordination between authorities of state and centre regarding counseling schedule and procedure. We could not find any link of On-line Resignation first and here state counseling administration did not respond to any phone call or e-mails provided on their sites. As there FAQs stated they would not give admission without original documents, administration of Kota college also refused to accept affidavit. Again my brother started from Jaipur to Bihar to resign from last alloted college and get original documents back. And after traveling for 3-4 days continuously to Bihar and back they reached GMC, Kota on last reporting day.
Now we had resigned from AIPMT and we could continue with state counseling only.In second counseling my brother was alloted Medical College, Kota again.
After this round of counseling complete administration regressed to last century and started off-line counseling. All enrolled candidates(almost all except who were alloted their first choice) reached at the venue. Hundreds of people reached at the venue from distant locations ( candidates for at least 900 seats and their parents). They were doing counseling for seats remained vacant in state counseling and vacant seats transferred from AIPMT. After feeling like being in an auction, around 4-5 hours later counseling was stopped in between and again after wait of 4-5 hours it was announced counseling was being canceled because somebody had brought Court Stay.
Next day, their site flashed that counseling would be conducted on upcoming Monday and would be done for state seats only. Again people thronged in large number to the same venue and counseling was done for 6-7 seats remaining vacant in same fashion of auctioning shown in movies. Later it was announced again that one more round of counseling would be done and it was not clear they were doing it for vacant seats of AIPMT or not.
Same no. of people were again on the venue after few days. And Counseling was started for State Seats only. Somebody declared that for seats of AIPMT, provisional counseling would be done and further court decision would be deciding! We didn't opt for it.
So this travel of one place to another for one month, experiencing mismanagement of Government we decided not to attend further rounds of counseling and stay in our alloted college in first round.
Experiencing it all for one month, mismanagement and unfairness that I can point out:
i) There was no fixed procedure of MCC that needed to be adhered to in counseling.
ii) State and central administration were not in synchronisation.
iii) people consider a seat in medical college saving of at least a crore, so any complain is disregarded by derisive comments like, you have saved this much amount now don't fiddle with anything. (We actually listened this statement thrice at least.)
iv) In off-line counseling people are called in rank wise and Security Guard's any whim can take a less scorer inside and tag a high scorer late comer. ( This actually happened with us, though we could not check as they refused to show us the list of allocation.)
v) With the procedure or FAQs, reasons of that procedure should also be published to get review of others and to provide a feeling of satisfaction. ( I couldn't identify what was the need of reporting physically to every reported college and original document submission.)
iv) No optimum utilisation of power of digitalisation. If at this level you can not implement power of computer and Internet, how can you talk of reaching this out to poor and illiterates.
Second case: I got a job in CGA of accountant through SSC. The final result was announced 6 months back and from then I wait for letters through post office and then going back and forth to different departments for completion of formalities. Recent case is of Police Verification, It has been 1 and a half month when one constable did this police verification at home and from then I am waiting to get it received by alloted department and intermittently traveling to Police Station, Commissionerate and Collectorate to track and cajoling them to move it forward.
No comments:
Post a Comment